Gear Report

Cast Iron: What to Buy, What to Skip, and the One Pan You'll Use Daily

Five pieces, two verdicts you won't like. The 12-inch skillet is the only one that earns the stovetop.

This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.

Cast iron gets sold as a lifestyle. It’s a pan. A good one is cheap, heavy and will outlive you, and that’s the whole pitch. The catch is that the same qualities that make the skillet great make half the other shapes a waste of cabinet space.

Here are six pieces, ranked by how often they actually came off the shelf over three years of cooking for a family in a kitchen with a normal gas range. Two of them you don’t need.

The 12-inch skillet

12 in across the top, about 8 lb, pre-seasoned

12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Used it five nights a week for three years. Steaks, cornbread, eggs, fajitas, a whole chicken. Heavy enough to hold heat, wide enough for two of everything.

If you buy one piece of cast iron, this is it. Twelve inches across the top, about ten at the cooking surface, eight pounds. That mass is the point: it holds heat when a cold steak hits it and gives you a crust a thin pan can’t.

What it did this week: two ribeyes, a pan of cornbread, a pound of fajita meat, a Dutch baby, breakfast tacos for four. It goes stove to oven to grill. Preheat it five minutes over medium before anything touches it, and you’ve solved most of what people think is a cast iron problem.

The 10-inch skillet

10 in, about 5 lb

10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

The one-person pan. Two eggs and bacon fit; a steak and a side don't. Buy it second, or get the 12 and never think about it.

Fine. Lighter, easier for one person, fits two eggs and three slices of bacon. Doesn’t fit a steak and a side, doesn’t fit cornbread for a crowd. If you cook for one or two, this can be your main pan. If you cook for more, you’ll reach past it for the 12 every night. Buy it as the second skillet, not the first.

The Dutch oven

5 to 7 qt, lid, about 13 lb

Cast Iron Dutch Oven (5 to 7 quart, bare or enameled)

Chili, beans, braises, bread. Enameled costs more and skips the seasoning routine; bare is cheaper and goes over a fire. Either works. Get one.

The other piece that earns its weight. Six quarts of heavy iron with a heavy lid holds a simmer at the lowest burner setting without scorching, which is the difference between chili and burnt chili. It bakes bread, braises a shoulder, cooks a pot of beans all afternoon and goes camping.

Bare or enameled is a real choice. Bare is cheaper, tougher and goes directly in a campfire. Enameled doesn’t need seasoning, doesn’t react with acidic things and wipes clean. For a kitchen pot, enameled. For the one that travels, bare.

The griddle

About 17 by 9 in, spans two burners, 10 to 12 lb

Reversible Cast Iron Griddle (grill and flat side)

Great for a dozen tortillas or pancakes for a crowd, twice a year. The rest of the time it lives in the cabinet and hits your knuckles.

A reversible griddle across two burners is the right tool for pancakes for eight or a stack of tortillas. That’s a Saturday a few times a year. The rest of the time it’s twelve pounds of iron in the bottom cabinet that you lift out to reach the colander.

Borrow one from whoever has it when you’re feeding a crowd. If you find yourself borrowing it every month, buy it. Most people won’t.

The wok

14 in, flat bottom, about 12 lb

Cast Iron Wok

Takes ten minutes to heat and never gets hot enough on a home burner for the thing woks are for. A carbon steel wok weighs a third and works better.

Skip it. A wok works by getting very hot, very fast, and cooling off the moment you move food up the sides. Cast iron does the opposite: slow to heat, slow to cool, and a home burner can’t push enough heat into twelve pounds of iron to get a proper sear on a handful of vegetables. A $25 carbon steel wok weighs four pounds and does the job it was designed for.

The scrubber

Stainless rings, about 7 by 7 in

Chainmail Scrubber

Takes off stuck food without taking off seasoning. Replaces the salt-and-paper-towel routine and the argument about soap.

Not a pan, but it ends the maintenance debate. Hot water, a chainmail scrubber, and stuck-on fajita bits are gone in twenty seconds without touching the seasoning. A drop of dish soap is fine; modern soap doesn’t strip polymerized oil, whatever your uncle says. Dry it on the burner for a minute, wipe a thin film of oil on, hang it up.

The short version

Buy the 12-inch skillet and a Dutch oven, enameled for the kitchen or bare for the fire. Add the chainmail scrubber. Get the 10-inch later if you want a small pan. Borrow a griddle. Skip the wok. Two pans and a scrubber, about $90, and it’s the last cookware you buy for that job.

While you're here